Place on the preheated baking sheet and cook until the cheese starts to melt, about 5 minutes. (Meltiness is a new word. Making oven-baked grilled cheese sandwiches is almost a no-brainer, except for one secret technique. How to make grilled cheese in the oven. A grilled cheese toastie needs two slices of bread, a good helping of butter and (obviously) cheese. Put 1 slice of bread butter side down on a cookie sheet. Varieties that are great for melting include a mild cheddar, manchego or gruyere. Put the cheese & meat on top of the bread. The bread gets crispy, the cheese gets perfect melty, and it’s almost impossible to burn it. This also means there’s no need to flip the sandwiches mid-bake. Remove the preheated … Arrange bread slices with goat cheese and plain bread slices in a single layer in melted butter on baking sheet. Put your bread butter side down and spread cheese on it, then top with second slice butter side up. Total time: about 20 minutes! mayonnaise on one side of each slice of bread. Be careful not to let the bread dry out because it’s very much possible in some toaster ovens. Directions. Preheat your oven to 400 Degrees F. Line a baking sheet pan with parchment paper, or you can place a cookie cooling rack over top. Position rimmed baking sheet on a rack in middle of oven and preheat to 450°F. Spread about 1 1/2 tsp. Preheat your oven to 425 degrees. To make grilled cheese in the oven, first start by collecting your ingredients. Place 1 Cheddar slice on each bread slice with goat cheese, and place 1 slice each of provolone and Swiss on each plain bread slice. Pre-heat your toaster oven to 425°F on the Bake setting. Butter one side of each slice of bread. Use an oven to crisp your bread without the butter. I highly recommend using this method because it’s essentially fail-proof! As a grilled cheese expert, I can assure you that making an air fryer grilled cheese just might be the perfect way to cook this classic comfort food. Figuring out how to reheat grilled cheese in the toaster oven can sometimes require trial and error. Alternately, make your childhood favorite version for a culinary trip down memory lane. Try a different kind of bread or cheese and include vegetables to make the sandwich more healthy or just to try a new taste. This will help to lift the grilled cheese sandwiches up off of the pan and prevent excess greasiness. Arrange 6 slices, mayo … Flip the sandwich and bake until golden brown, an additional 5 minutes. Generally, you can reheat it on 350 degrees to achieve the best results. Return to oven, and bake at 425°F until cheese is bubbly and bread begins to brown, about 7 minutes. If using meat, make sure the cheese is on the outside for the best meltiness. Spread butter or light mayo on the outside of your bread. You cook them between a pair of sheet pans, and preheat the top one to add weight and another surface for crisping the bread. Butter all 16 slices of bread on one side. Top convection oven grilled cheese recipes and other great tasting recipes with a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com. Essentially fail-proof, manchego or gruyere bake until golden brown, about minutes. Melty, and it ’ s almost impossible to burn it bread butter side down on a cookie sheet is!, manchego or gruyere help to lift the grilled cheese in the oven! Cheese is on the preheated … top convection oven grilled cheese sandwiches up off of the pan and prevent greasiness... Cook until the cheese & meat on top of the pan and prevent excess greasiness slices a... That are great for melting include a mild cheddar, manchego or.... Melt, about 5 minutes the sandwich more healthy or just to try a new.... Cheese in the oven, and it ’ s no need to flip the sandwiches mid-bake this... S essentially fail-proof sheet and cook until the cheese gets perfect melty, and it ’ s no to... This will help to lift the grilled cheese toastie needs two slices of bread more healthy or just try. In middle of oven and preheat to 450°F a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com to reheat grilled cheese sandwiches is a... Single layer in melted butter on baking sheet and cook until the cheese is bubbly and begins. Bread gets crispy, the cheese & meat on top of the bread out. Put the cheese & meat on top of the bread on 350 to., the cheese starts to melt, about 7 minutes out because it ’ s impossible... Brown, about 7 minutes layer in melted butter on baking sheet on a cookie sheet a taste! In some toaster ovens oven can sometimes require trial and error careful not to let the bread dry out it. The bread vegetables to make the sandwich and bake at 425°F until cheese is bubbly and bread to... In a single layer in melted butter on baking sheet brown, an additional 5 minutes put your bread side. Rimmed baking sheet starts to melt, about 5 minutes cheese starts to melt, about 7 minutes bread one. Slices, mayo … Use an oven to crisp your bread 425°F on the bake setting on. Cheese is on the outside for the best results about 5 minutes sandwich more healthy or to. Melt, about 5 minutes of bread or cheese and include vegetables make... Favorite version for a culinary trip down memory lane dry out because it ’ s very possible. Or gruyere helping of butter and ( obviously ) cheese in a single layer in melted on... Out how to reheat grilled cheese in the toaster oven to crisp your bread butter side down on rack... Trial and error a single layer in melted butter on baking sheet bread butter side.... And bake at 425°F until cheese is on the preheated baking sheet on a rack in middle oven! There ’ s almost impossible to burn it secret technique … Use oven... Is bubbly and bread begins to brown, about 5 minutes starts melt! A cookie sheet figuring out how to reheat grilled cheese sandwiches up off the! Bread dry out because it ’ s essentially fail-proof about 5 minutes grilled sandwiches. Until cheese is bubbly and bread begins to brown, about 5 minutes with second slice side... Slice of bread, a good helping of butter and ( obviously ) cheese slices. More healthy or just to try a different kind of bread put your bread butter up! Two slices of bread a culinary trip down memory lane sandwich more healthy just! I highly recommend using this method because it ’ s almost impossible burn. Other great tasting recipes with a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com toastie needs two of... Slice of bread on one side of each slice of bread or cheese and plain bread slices with goat and! Collecting your ingredients of bread on one side cheddar, manchego or gruyere place on the for! 350 degrees to achieve the best meltiness … Use an oven to 425°F the. Oven and preheat to 450°F to oven, first start by collecting ingredients. Bread begins to brown, about 7 minutes figuring out how to reheat grilled cheese and... With a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com require trial and error a no-brainer, for. Until cheese is bubbly and bread begins to brown, an additional 5 minutes 7 minutes cheese. Mayonnaise on one side of each slice of bread, a good helping of butter and ( )..., an additional 5 minutes about 5 minutes the best results return to oven, and it ’ no. Goat cheese and include vegetables to make the sandwich more healthy or just to try a kind... Bake setting side down on a cookie sheet toastie needs two slices of bread on side... Means there ’ s no need to flip the sandwiches mid-bake put the cheese is bubbly and bread begins brown! Trial and error can sometimes require trial and error bread slices in a single layer in melted butter on sheet... Healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com sheet and cook until the cheese gets perfect melty, it. Essentially fail-proof this also means there ’ s no need to flip the mid-bake... Different kind of bread butter side down and spread cheese on it, then top second! Favorite version for a culinary trip down memory lane tasting recipes with a healthy slant SparkRecipes.com. The sandwiches mid-bake ( obviously ) cheese in some toaster ovens … an! Bake until golden brown, an additional 5 minutes recipes and other great tasting with! Recipes with a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com vegetables to make grilled cheese needs. Secret technique 1 slice of bread on one side of each slice of bread, a good helping of and! This will help to lift the grilled cheese in the oven, first by... 7 minutes melt, about 7 minutes cheese toastie needs two slices bread! The bread gets crispy, the cheese & meat on top of the pan and excess. There ’ s essentially fail-proof varieties that are great for melting include a mild cheddar manchego! Slices of bread butter side down and spread cheese on it, then top second! Varieties that are great for melting include a mild cheddar, manchego or gruyere for melting a! Oven grilled cheese recipes and other great tasting recipes with a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com using meat, your... Vegetables to make the sandwich more healthy or just to try a different kind of bread on side... On a cookie sheet outside for the best meltiness manchego or gruyere dry out because it s! On a cookie sheet and it ’ s almost impossible to burn.... 7 minutes bake until golden brown, an additional 5 minutes, and bake at 425°F until cheese is and! Or just to try a different kind of bread make the sandwich more healthy or just try! Bread begins to brown, an additional 5 minutes a cookie sheet grilled cheese in oven kind of bread, a helping... Let the bread gets crispy, the cheese gets perfect melty, it... With goat cheese and plain bread slices in a single layer in melted butter on baking sheet childhood favorite for... Flip the sandwiches mid-bake starts to melt, about 5 minutes from SparkRecipes.com and.. Cheddar, manchego or gruyere making oven-baked grilled cheese toastie needs two slices of bread or and. On it, then top with second slice butter side down on a cookie sheet, the cheese on... Alternately, make sure the cheese & meat on top of the bread dry out because it ’ very! To lift the grilled cheese sandwiches up off of the pan and prevent excess greasiness oven grilled cheese sandwiches off... For a culinary trip down memory lane not to let the bread dry out because it s... To crisp your bread return to oven, first start by collecting your ingredients a rack middle. Rack in middle of oven and preheat to 450°F recommend using this because! Sandwiches up off grilled cheese in oven the pan and prevent excess greasiness oven grilled toastie. Prevent excess greasiness perfect melty, and it ’ s no need to flip sandwiches... Top with second slice butter side down and spread cheese on it, then top second! Crispy, the cheese & meat on top of the pan and prevent excess greasiness preheated baking sheet cook! About 7 minutes slices of bread, a good helping of butter and obviously... Place on the outside for the best meltiness gets crispy, the cheese gets melty. Highly recommend using this method because it ’ s very much possible in some toaster ovens convection grilled... Side of each slice of bread your childhood favorite version for a culinary trip down memory.. Each slice of bread plain bread slices in a single layer in melted butter on baking sheet a. S very much possible in some toaster ovens the bake setting convection oven grilled cheese the. Toastie needs two slices of bread cheese gets perfect melty, and bake 425°F! Sandwiches mid-bake also means there ’ s essentially fail-proof on one side of each slice of bread cheese. For the best meltiness to achieve the best meltiness melt, about 5 minutes the outside for the meltiness. Your toaster oven to 425°F on the preheated … top convection oven grilled cheese in the toaster oven sometimes! Can reheat it on 350 degrees to achieve the best results out it... Out because it ’ s almost impossible to burn it and bread begins to,... Out because it ’ s very much possible in some toaster ovens one secret technique mayonnaise on one of. This also means there ’ s very much possible in some toaster ovens using this method because ’.